New Year, Old Year: 2016 Revisited

Day Five: Unique

What I Got Right!

Probably the most significant success from this list is Inis, which still feels like it came out no more than three months ago. That’s how fresh it feels. Dudes on a map, but inhabiting a system that isn’t interested in the usual dice-thwacking. Instead, it’s a game of escalating politics, policing the best cards to get the job done, and very carefully hindering anyone who inches within grasping distance of the crown. It’s king-making at its subtle best.

Most-played? Easily Captain Sonar. It’s common for us to have large numbers of visitors at game night, coupled with an unreasonable unwillingness to break into groups. Only a handful of games both accommodate teams and get people stressed enough to move onto something calmer once their submarine has been scuttled. At that point, smoother fare includes Vast: The Crystal Caverns, which is still the king of wild asymmetry that actually works, and Millennium Blades, which remains my favorite game to include mental bandwidth as its primary resource. Both are tremendous examples of what can be done when a genre doesn’t exist, so you invent it.

Finally, while I didn’t play as much Star Trek: Ascendancy or Scythe as I would have liked, both remain games that I’m very unlikely to turn down. They’re also polar opposites. Where Ascendancy revels in its sprawling playtime and table commitment, wild negotiations, and dog-pile conclusions, Scythe is a measured game of economics and the occasional timber raid or doomsday invention. Their only real parallel is that both were further improved by expansions.

What I Got Wrong!

For the sake of argument, I’m being as critical as possible here. In any other situation, I wouldn’t regard Zimby Mojo as a failure. For one thing, it’s about as wacky as games get. Set up like a bloodier version of capture the flag, wherein everybody is after the same well-protected flag, Zimby Mojo lets you raise zombies, cast spells that break the board, and join into temporary alliances of yowling cannibals.

So what’s the problem? The length and the fact that it’s sort of difficult to explain. And that’s it. Even the best of games are hard to get to the table when their conclusion is so long in coming.

Even more surprising, at the time Star Wars: Rebellion did the impossible by making me care about Jedis and Death Stars. By casting the two sides of its conflict as entirely distinct, with the Rebellion skittering from hiding place to hiding place while the Empire rooted them out with superior force, it presented an idiosyncratic take on galactic war. Rather than trying to win outright, it was a game of hearts and minds, counterinsurgency, and hanging on for just one extra turn.

Unfortunately, it was hampered by a disappointing combat system, a lengthy playtime, and far too few moments where the Star had any Wars going on. Whether the expansion will mend these flaws has yet to be seen, because I’m on Dan Standard Time and haven’t gotten around to it.

Score: 6/8

There you have it! The ravages of time afflict all things. Have any of your favorite games of 2016 changed in your estimation?

Posted on February 10, 2018, in Board Game, Lists and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 11 Comments.

  1. Happy Salmon is a true winner, never fails to warm up a crowd!

  2. Ferox is one of my favorite games! I would love to hear your recommendations for similar or better games along that vein. Thanks for all the incredible game reviews and coverage—I look forward to your work and always enjoy your take on this hobby.

    • I’m not sure I would say anything is precisely like Ferox. But in terms of clever two-player card games, I’d rather spend time mastering Omen: A Reign of War, Codex, or Summoner Wars.

  3. Out of curiosity: how many times have you played Food Chain Magnate? I’m a bit surprised when you say “overrated” and wonders “overrated compared to what?”. It’s anyhow one of the most demanded game by my friends. As a big fan of both Pax Renaissance and Pamir (latter more accessible for new players and the former a notch more intriguing), I rate FCM as equal. It’s of course a matter of taste and no big deal.

    • I’ve played Food Chain Magnate eight times, and probably received three plays’ worth of enjoyment between them. Any game where you can lose on the first round, only to be locked into a three-hour purgatory before the game has the decency to conclude, is not going to rate highly in my book.

      Also, “overrated” does not mean “bad.” It means overrated. Food Chain Magnate is a perfectly decent game that garners more attention than the design merits.

      Though the same can be said of much of the BGG Top 100.

      • I respect your viewpoint. Yes, it might be a probability if the map becomes too funky. However we choose to evaluate the map before deciding to start a round and the shifting synergies between players usually makes it a tight race.

        Overrated or underrated? I only play what I think is fun and don’t have the knowledge to conclude anything beyond what I like and dislike. Among BGG Top 100? Games like Caverna are of no interest to me, as it in my taste becomes a pointless exercise of tons of options for no good logical reason, but if it’s overrated I don’t know.

        To conclude: thanks for your articles about the Pax games, because otherwise I might not have noticed them.

  4. Awesome list of games I will investigate once my pile of unplayed gets smaller.

  5. This is one of my favorite features in board gaming. I feel like too few people revisit titles down the road to see how they hold up and discuss them further when they’ve had more time to really sink in. I’m so glad you started doing this.

    • I’m glad you approve, Dale. With a thousand new games springing into existence every year, it’s too easy to ride the hype train. This is the sort of thing that keeps me grounded.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: