New Year, Old Year: 2016 Revisited

Day Four: Lessons!

What I Got Right!

Another easy list. Either I’m getting the hang of this or 2016 was a strong year.

Kolejka/Queue remains one of my favorite “message games” of all time, in part because it wholeheartedly embraces its status as a cultural artifact. The crinkled paper graphic of its box, the cheapo pawns, the fact that Russia actually banned the thing — if that isn’t how you promote your game about the evils of the Soviet regime, I don’t know what to tell you.

Other historical examples also made for easy selections. While it wasn’t without its share of flaws, Black Orchestra at least provided a rejoinder for anyone who claims that they would have just shot Hitler and been done with it. Buddy, when that punk has evaded poison gas, a sabotaged airplane, and a kidnapped convoy, your best bet is hoping he just does the job himself.

Tension was also the order of the day in 13 Days: The Cuban Missile Crisis and An Infamous Traffic, although for very different reasons. While 13 Days didn’t entirely recapture the world-ending brinkmanship of Twilight Struggle in 45 minutes, it came dang close, especially once the DEFCON levels began plummeting like a Lockheed U-2 in 1960. An Infamous Traffic, meanwhile, was possibly the worst a game has let me behave. Whether using missionaries to hook people on opium or starting wars to sell more opium — or, crud, just selling opium in the first place — the tension of waiting for an opposing firm to undercut your prices was almost as bad as the crap you were pulling.

My two personal favorites wound up being Falling Sky and Pax Renaissance, both of which have reappeared on my table multiple times over the past year. Falling Sky because it was a shockingly good translation of the COIN System into a time period just a scootch before the invention of the AK-47, and Pax Renaissance for modeling pretty much every sphere of influence that led to the world shifting from the Medieval into something resembling today. Politics, capital, class, religion, sovereignty, trade, the cross-pollination of cultures — if you can think it, there’s a good chance Pax Renaissance had some way to shove it into its tiny box.

What I Got Wrong!

Most contentiously, Food Chain Magnate is still overrated, and nothing over the past year has disavowed me of that belief. It’s probably the build orders. Or maybe the milestones running counter to the possibility of creative play. Or the way it brags about its lack of chance while still being a very chancy game.

Nah. It’s the build orders.

Tesla vs. Edison also didn’t make the long-term cut, though it’s still the sort of design that’s easy to respect, especially once its expansion hit the scene. Still, there’s a certain brittleness to the way it unfolds, from beat to beat more often than naturally, that makes it less interesting on its fifth play than its first. Ultimately, lighting up America felt like the sort of process that only needed to occur once.

Score: 6/8

On the next page, we’re talking about the most unique games of 2016 and how well they held up.

Posted on February 10, 2018, in Board Game, Lists and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 11 Comments.

  1. Happy Salmon is a true winner, never fails to warm up a crowd!

  2. Ferox is one of my favorite games! I would love to hear your recommendations for similar or better games along that vein. Thanks for all the incredible game reviews and coverage—I look forward to your work and always enjoy your take on this hobby.

    • I’m not sure I would say anything is precisely like Ferox. But in terms of clever two-player card games, I’d rather spend time mastering Omen: A Reign of War, Codex, or Summoner Wars.

  3. Out of curiosity: how many times have you played Food Chain Magnate? I’m a bit surprised when you say “overrated” and wonders “overrated compared to what?”. It’s anyhow one of the most demanded game by my friends. As a big fan of both Pax Renaissance and Pamir (latter more accessible for new players and the former a notch more intriguing), I rate FCM as equal. It’s of course a matter of taste and no big deal.

    • I’ve played Food Chain Magnate eight times, and probably received three plays’ worth of enjoyment between them. Any game where you can lose on the first round, only to be locked into a three-hour purgatory before the game has the decency to conclude, is not going to rate highly in my book.

      Also, “overrated” does not mean “bad.” It means overrated. Food Chain Magnate is a perfectly decent game that garners more attention than the design merits.

      Though the same can be said of much of the BGG Top 100.

      • I respect your viewpoint. Yes, it might be a probability if the map becomes too funky. However we choose to evaluate the map before deciding to start a round and the shifting synergies between players usually makes it a tight race.

        Overrated or underrated? I only play what I think is fun and don’t have the knowledge to conclude anything beyond what I like and dislike. Among BGG Top 100? Games like Caverna are of no interest to me, as it in my taste becomes a pointless exercise of tons of options for no good logical reason, but if it’s overrated I don’t know.

        To conclude: thanks for your articles about the Pax games, because otherwise I might not have noticed them.

  4. Awesome list of games I will investigate once my pile of unplayed gets smaller.

  5. This is one of my favorite features in board gaming. I feel like too few people revisit titles down the road to see how they hold up and discuss them further when they’ve had more time to really sink in. I’m so glad you started doing this.

    • I’m glad you approve, Dale. With a thousand new games springing into existence every year, it’s too easy to ride the hype train. This is the sort of thing that keeps me grounded.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: