Best Week 2013: Head-to-Heads

The best part of this game was its awesome laser-cut meeples. For five space pennies, what was it?

Here we are on day four of Best Week 2013, and we’ve finally arrived at my favorite topic: head-to-head games. Dueling games. Nobody-else-to-save-you games. Can’t-blame-your- teammate-when-you-lose games. Two minds locked in ultimate combat, the only other people at the table mere spectators, holding their breath and occasionally mumbling unwanted advice before your backhand slap shuts them up again.

Because this is my favorite genre by far, in place of the usual top five list, today we’re looking at the top ten. Buckle up.

Contrary to popular belief, the "incident" in The Valkyrie Incident was fairly low-key, the passage of a Congress resolution that only permitted valkyrie-babes into the armed services.

Valkyries and hulking machines go to war.

#10. The Valkyrie Incident

I still don’t know what the “incident” in The Valkyrie Incident is referring to, and I don’t care, because very few companies pull off the horizontal-area-control genre or hand drafting with as much panache as Small Box Games.

You’ll be drafting a lot. The game kicks off with a drafting phase, and roughly half of each round sees both players drafting even more. It’s a relief then that the stuff you’re drafting is so cool, from war-babe valkyries with game-changing special abilities to “cogdrive” battle-robots and orbital bombardments. Then you send all those nifty cards you’ve drafted into the fray, trumping each other over and over again as your cards stack in mind-bending ways that will have your opponent swearing you’re somehow breaking the rules. At least until it’s his turn and he gets to do the same back to you.

The Valkyrie Incident isn’t the best title from Small Box Games, but it’s definitely worth a look if you’ve played any of their other stuff.

NOT a staged shot!

Raiding the Vault of Darkness.

#9. Hemloch: Vault of Darkness

Speaking of other stuff from Small Box Games, number nine on our list is Hemloch: Vault of Darkness, spiritual sequel to Hemloch from a few years back.

Although Vault of Darkness shares a couple similarities with The Valkyrie Incident, most notably its horizontal-area-control style, which casts you as one of the power-hungry and corrupt houses of the twilight city of Hemloch, the differences are more profound. Where The Valkyrie Incident is about drafting an army and beating your opponent over the head with it, Vault of Darkness is more about subtlety, about outguessing and preempting your opponent’s moves as you both make use of the titular Vault of Darkness’s relics to send your agents throughout the city to curry favor, manipulate its Nightmare Before Christmas-esque politics, and sometimes resort to good old-fashioned assassination.

Sure, you could use that one card to take solid control of the Alley Maze, but as soon as you pass the vault’s relics to your opponent, what are they planning on doing? Maybe capitalizing on their position in the Boneyard? Or killing off one of your agents to swing the popular vote in the Spires? Should you cut off their plans, or bellow forward with your own? Full of nagging doubts and multiple ways to gain influence and win control for your household, Hemloch: Vault of Darkness is a great entry-point for anyone interested in Small Box Games’ unique brand of gameplay.

He's in danger of enemy assault, but *never* in danger of having his facial hair insulted.

Putting a friendly cube into a tight spot.

#8. Cube Quest

While I usually prefer mind-crunching anxiety and the possibility of ended friendships in my dueling games, sometimes I just want to flick the shit out of something, even if it means having my buddy lift up the couch so I can fish out a game component. In those instances, one of the quickest options out there is Cube Quest.

This tight little dexterity game might suffer from some production issues, from folded mats to over-light cubes, but ultimately those problems stop mattering the instant you realize it takes literally ten minutes to play, and it’s a breeze to create a tower of grunts and blast one of your heavy raider cubes off the top for the win. You probably won’t even notice that the cube’s weight wasn’t enough to keep it from sailing under the refrigerator. At least not right away.

Cube Quest would have been a fine game in an even more basic form, but it’s happy to let you play around by building an army full of freeze spells and medics, or sneak infiltrators around onto the enemy’s side of the board. It’s light, but it’s the good kind of light.

No un-irradiated food left in Ziggy One, sadly.

McPherson doesn’t like his chances.

#7. The Convoy

Ignacy Trzewiczek already won our number one solo and cooperative game of the year with the sprawling and ambitious Robinson Crusoe: Adventure on the Cursed Island, but somewhere between designing that masterpiece and running Portal Games, he decided to try his hand at invading the territory of Small Box Games with a horizontal-area-control game of his own. The result was The Convoy, set in the same desperate post-apocalyptic world as Neuroshima Hex and 51st State. And let me tell you, this game is brutal.

For one thing, unlike most of these types of games, its two factions are entirely asymmetrical, right down to their respective objectives. You could play as the marching army of Moloch, the game’s “convoy” of murder-machines bent on wiping out humanity for good. These guys fill their ranks with obscenely deadly troops, gradually rolling over the landscape and leaving only smoldering ruins in their wake. Or you could play as the good-guy Outpost faction, mobile and tricky and ready to fight to the death at established hardpoints to keep new-New York from disappearing beneath a tide of genocidal robots.

Like the best games of this genre, The Convoy is mean, letting you and your opponent set up long-form strategies, army compositions, and emplacements, only for the appearance of a single well-timed unit to topple your position like a house of (literal) cards. As the Moloch horde pushes past your EMP cannons and rolls over Cleveland, you’ll swear you’ve never been so invested in the fates of a bunch of fictional post-apocalyptic commandos. Then you’ll swear in a different way.

Now with an even better-fitting hood.

Beware the Roc (Second Edition)!

#6. BattleLore (Second Edition)

I admit it, I’m a sucker for spectacle. Which isn’t to say BattleLore (Second Edition) is only about the whizbangs, what with its adept use of the “Commands & Colors” battle format, clever scenario generation, smooth translation to the Terrinoth/RuneBound setting, and badass game-altering lore cards. But still, there’s something to be said about how fantastic it looks set up on the table. I’ve had friends who normally can’t stand two-player dueling-type games walk in on an in-progress match of BattleLore, only to gasp and ask if they can play the winner.

Really, it isn’t only about how damn good it looks. It’s also fairly simple to pick up on, and the armies are neat and do their own thing, and the scenarios are dynamic and fresh, and for such a big game it only takes about an hour and a half to get through an entire battle.

But seriously, it looks fabulous.

Big money

I’ve got $1.56 riding on this game.

#5. Coin Age

Adam P. McIver’s Coin Age will only cost you a refundable $1.56 to play. That’s because it’s a print-and-play game that could fit on an index card with room to spare, so you could play at McDonald’s and buy some sort of crappy artificial hamburger that will likely give you colon cancer afterwards.

Because you can print it and play it right this very instant, you don’t need me to tell you how good it is. That it’s so compact that the recent successful Kickstarter campaign is going to put the game on a board the size of a credit card. That it uses its coins like two-sided dice, and allows for some shockingly deep gameplay that sees you taking control of a pun-filled kingdom with heads- or tails-themed armies. That the physical size of your coins is a brilliant shorthand for how powerful your troops are.

You don’t need to hear all that, because you’re already printing it off. You won’t regret it.

Filled with cuties too! The Leaf Seer! The Rousing (wink wink) Mystic! The... Gorgon? Hm.

The best Small Box Game of all time.

#4. Omen: A Reign of War: Olympus Edition

Appearing on this list for the third time is Small Box Games, this time with a reprint and legacy edition of their best game of all time, Omen: A Reign of War.

I play Omen weekly, and it probably would have been #1 on this list if the Olympus Edition wasn’t a reprint of a game I’ve been talking and writing about for ages now (“ages” means a little over a year in Space-Biff! time). It’s got everything The Valkyrie Incident has and more: excellent drafting, awesome soldiers, tight mechanics, constant combo-making and combo-breaking, a broad decision space laden with choice-landmines and a vindictive opponent whose cards are every bit as broken and terrifying as yours. It’s full of clever mechanics, a tough economy, and oh so much blood and carnage.

The one downside is that this is probably the last printing of Omen: A Reign of War that Small Box Games will ever do. I hope that’s not true, because this game deserves to be played and enjoyed by everybody who can get their hands on it.

I can, but only because I'm a genius. Or because I have a raging case of OCD. Hopefully the former.

From Pixel Tactics 2, not that you could tell the difference.

#3. Pixel Tactics 1 & 2

Last year’s Minigames Library from Level 99 Games included a bevy of interesting titles, the most excellent of which was Pixel Tactics. This year, they followed it up with Pixel Tactics 2, which was more of the same, but when the same is nigh-perfect, why muck it up with innovation?

In a way, Pixel Tactics feels like an “accidental” success, like it’s something designer Brad Talton Jr. thought up on the can or in a dream or something. Although it doesn’t look it, it’s rather brilliantly simple, each card actually representing five different units depending on its placement in your army. The result is hard to take pictures of, since each card looks so cluttered, but once the rules click into place you’re presented with a brutal dance between two parties of warring heroes. You’ll have heroes who are great defenders, ranged attackers, necromancers, and one-shot superbuffs, all at once, contingent on how you decide to use them. It allows for endless replayability. Especially once you merge the two decks together and settle in for a best-of-five tournament.

I dare you.

Look closely for thirty seconds and tell me you don’t know what’s going on.

#2. The Duke

The Duke is the most readable game of the year. It’s also the one game I managed to play with my father that he actually liked, probably because it’s filled with so much universal appeal. You know, since it’s kind of like chess, but not boring.

To follow the chess angle, imagine chess but with the ability to call for reinforcements during the game, pieces that switch between two modes as they move and attack, and an abundance of pieces that doesn’t over-complicate the proceedings thanks to the game’s perfectly clear visual language that shows you each soldier’s abilities right on his face. If what you’re now imagining isn’t board game nirvana, you pictured it wrong.

I say this without hyperbole: this is the one game I’d recommend to anybody, anywhere, regardless of their taste in other games. Even if its tile-flipping conceit is too much to wrap your head around (though it shouldn’t be), it’s going to look gentlemanly as hell on your drawing room coffee table. Even if you don’t have a coffee table or drawing room, it’ll transform your trailer’s kitchen/bathroom combo into something resembling a drawing room once you get The Duke up in there.

This caption sums up Devastation's ONE downside. The names are bonkers.

King Alexian XXXVII vs Ottavia Six!

#1. BattleCON: Devastation of Indines

Level 99 Games is at it again. If Pixel Tactics was a success, Devastation of Indines (endearingly called “Devastion of Indians” at our house because of my failure to enunciate when first introducing it) is the game that won World War Two. It’s a fighting game, and it won my heart even though my life history with fighting games consists mostly of getting kicked off the local arcade by a gang of mean teenagers, losing lots of Power Stone, and then losing lots of Smash Bros.

In spite of the thirty distinct fighters that come in the box, each with their own utterly unique fighting style, it’s ultimately a fairly simple game about bluffing and outguessing your opponent. You pick a combo of base card and style card, maybe beef them up with tokens you’ve earned, then reveal and resolve. It all comes down to watching your opponent as he pretends he doesn’t notice you watching him, trying to figure out whether he’s going to dash to safety or press the attack, or shoot a ranged blast or go into fatality mode, or throw you into a corner or dance around the board until some of his other powers recharge. Each move has just enough going on to create the best kind of agony I’ve felt all year, but not so much as to overwhelm. Best of all, every battle rides on your smarts and ability to outperform your opponent, not how lucky you are at tossing dice or drawing cards.

There we have it — my Top Ten Two-Player Games of the Year! What are yours?

Posted on December 30, 2013, in Board Game, Lists and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink. 24 Comments.

  1. Lots of really good picks on this list, but my own list would have definitely included Android: Netrunner, the best customizable card game I have ever played.

    • I was on the verge of including it, but some folks got grumpy when I included games from 2012 on my solo / co-op top five, so I dropped it. It was the only holdover from last year, so it wasn’t a big deal to make the change.

      Anyway — I agree, Netrunner is amazing.

      • Three things:

        One, this was a great best-of list, so well done! I haven’t played everything on it yet (still waiting to get my hands on The Duke and Devastation of Indines, and I hadn’t even heard of The Convoy or a couple of the Small Box Games), so thanks for a good read and some great recommendations! That’s exactly what I hope to get out of a Top Ten list.

        Two, screw those people. Board games often garner awards in the year following their release, because, get this, they’re a lot harder to review than a movie or album. Also, distribution deals are often delayed or staggered, so complaining that Robinson Crusoe came out in 2012 when its English release was in mid-2013 is asinine. What were you supposed to do, learn Polish? Or get your hands on one of the rare and expensive early translations?

        Three, I love Netrunner! I would have put it on this list too. 😉

      • Thanks for your kind words, Sharpsley!

        If I’m permitted to do my top ten two-player games of all time, Netrunner’s definitely on there. Also Summoner Wars.

  2. If we’re throwing the release dates out of the window, my best head-to-head games this year are definitely Summoner Wars and Netrunner. In that order? Yes. No. Yes. Look, maybe, ok?

    And Memoir ’44 as an honourable mention.

    I haven’t managed to play my copy of The Duke yet, maybe this coming Friday though!

    Another quality list, keep up the good work 😉

    • And, as I’ve just been reminded, Revolver. That’s an absolutely lovely head-to-head game. I’ve played it a fair bit the last year or two and NEVER had a game of it I didn’t enjoy.

      A good friend of mine just got Revolver 2 for Christmas so I guess we”l see how that one plays very soon too!

      • I’m dying to try Revolver.

      • Another good thing about Revolver: it’s very reasonably priced. And it comes in a nice tin, though I know that’s not to everyone’s taste. (I’m looking at you, Thurot.)

      • Grr, tins. I got Forbidden Desert for Christmas, and I have nowhere to stash the thing.

        Though to be fair, it pales in comparison to the problems presented by that 27-pound copy of Ogre taking up half my living room.

  3. I’d like to propose trying out Chess 2 by David Sirlin. The rules can be gotten free of charge, and it plays with a regular chess set and a few tokens.

    As a big fan of Summoner Wars and the Duke, I report that Chess 2 has fortunately or unfortunately replaced them as my favourite two-player game. I still love SW and the Duke, but Chess 2 is easier to teach, deeper than expected, and quick to play.

    I have played it perhaps 20 times, and even if you’re skeptical, I hope you tty it just once. Free rules, easy learning, deep gameplay, and it really still plays a lot like chess.

    • You’ve convinced me! No skepticism here; I’m willing to try out any board game at least once, and if it’s good enough to sway a fan of SW and The Duke, it must be something special.

      Thanks for the tip — I’ll give it a try sometime in the next couple months and report back!

  4. What I love most about Space-Biff! is that it’s the only board game site I’ve ever seen where small stuff like Small Box Games or especially PnPs like Coin Age receive equal consideration with games from big publishers like Fantasy Flight Games. I’ve picked up over a dozen games on recommendations from Dan, many of them from smaller publishers, and I’ve always come away satisfied.

    Keep up the good work in 2014, brother. 🙂

  5. Good list.

  6. I only picked up The Duke a few days ago based on your earlier recommendation, Daniel. I just played it last night for the third time, and it has been well received by all three friends I’ve introduced it to. In fact, I think two of them are ready to pick it for themselves now. The Duke is a really fun game. I’m already looking forward to playing with the expansion tiles.

    My favorite 2-player game of 2013 was Polis: Fight for the Hegemony. That is one helluva game play experience and an amazingly good game. It’s one of top five all-time faves now. Though it may be hard to find until getting a second printing, I highly recommend you find a chance to play it. You won’t be disappointed.

  7. Few games make me buy them after I play them because I have access to a board game shops inventory I.e. The Innocents three overflowing book cases and room I never look in, that threaten to over take his basement. SW, Omen and the Duke won me over instantly though. For me the Duke just beats out Devastation of Indians because it’s so easy to jump into and play with beginners but I get the Indian guilt Innocent 😉

  1. Pingback: Best Week 2013: The (Other) Games of the Year | SPACE-BIFF!

  2. Pingback: Best Week 2013: The Index | SPACE-BIFF!

  3. Pingback: Time to brag. A little. | Boardgames That Tell Stories

  4. Pingback: A Wintry New Era for 51st State | SPACE-BIFF!

  5. Pingback: Welcome to Bright Sunny Indines | SPACE-BIFF!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: